April 2025– A growing number of retirees across the United States are learning that they may be receiving less in Social Security benefits than they are legally entitled to, due to the Social Security Administration’s (SSA) narrow interpretation of retroactive payment rules following the enactment of the Social Security Fairness Act.
The new law, effective January 2025, was hailed as a long-overdue correction to decades of benefit reductions caused by the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) and Government Pension Offset (GPO)—rules that disproportionately affected public sector workers, such as teachers, police officers, and firefighters.
The law promised retroactive payments dating back to January 2024, restoring benefits to those unfairly penalized. However, the SSA is currently limiting retroactive payments to just six months from the date of last contact, causing thousands of retirees to miss out on what could amount to over $5,500 annually in lost benefits.
“This silent cut is not only unfair—it’s financially devastating,” said a bipartisan group of senators who recently sent a formal letter to acting SSA Commissioner Leland Dudek, demanding an urgent policy review.
On average, the affected spousal benefit is around $931 per month. For many, the shortfall is the result of years of misinformation from SSA staff who incorrectly told retirees they did not qualify for certain benefits under the old rules. With the law now changed, those individuals do qualify—but are being denied full back pay due to a bureaucratic technicality.
Who’s affected?
Retired public employees and their spouses who were previously subject to GPO and WEP rules are at the center of this issue. Many were told they had no right to spousal or survivor benefits, only to discover in 2025 that they do. Unfortunately, unless they had a recent interaction with SSA, they’re likely receiving only a portion of what they are owed.
What retirees can do
If you believe you’re impacted:
- Review your benefit history through SSA’s official portal.
- Gather any documentation of previous interactions with SSA—even emails or call logs.
- File a claim or appeal for a review of your retroactive benefits.
- Contact a Social Security-focused attorney or advocacy group to assist with your case.
Public outcry and political pressure:
Senators from both sides of the aisle, including John Fetterman, Susan Collins, and Bill Cassidy, are pressing for a fair and comprehensive review. They argue that the SSA’s current policy undermines the very purpose of the Social Security Fairness Act.
“This is not just a policy oversight. It’s a broken promise to the people who kept our schools running and our cities safe,” said Kevin Thompson, a retirement analyst and CEO of 9i Capital Group.
Advertisement
What’s next?
Although the SSA has yet to publicly respond, pressure is mounting. Advocates warn that without prompt changes, the agency risks deepening financial hardship for the very people the law was designed to help.
For now, affected retirees are encouraged to stay informed, advocate for their rights, and push for fair treatment under the law.